Independent news. Deeper insight. Uzbekistan and beyond.

Listen to the article

0:00
0:00

Officials in Bukhara have denied that schoolchildren were made to carry desks and chairs during a building relocation, but video and photographic evidence submitted by parents directly contradicts that account, exposing a gap between the regional education authority’s public statement and what families witnessed at the weekend.

The dispute centres on School No. 42, a general secondary school in Bukhara city whose main building dates to 1958. The Bukhara Regional Education and Science Department confirmed that the structure had deteriorated sharply and that a letter from the regional Construction and Housing and Communal Services Inspectorate, dated 9 November 2026, formally declared the school buildings unfit for use and recommended they be taken out of service. Teaching is to continue in the vacant premises of School No. 44 and the Bukhara Law College while a longer-term solution is arranged.

What the Authority Said — and What Parents Filmed

The department stated that the furniture removal was carried out by technical staff and by parents who volunteered to help, and that pupils were not involved in the process. That account was issued in response to footage published earlier by Effect.uz showing children carrying desks and chairs.

Parents who submitted additional video and photographs to the outlet tell a different story. The material shows pupils physically transporting furniture on both Saturday and Sunday — days outside the regular school week. According to parents, children arrived home late on the Saturday and, when asked why, explained that a move was under way at the school and that they had been helping shift desks and chairs. Parents who returned the following day to check on their children found them still engaged in the same work. The footage was captured precisely because families wanted to verify whether their children were at school or elsewhere.

The discrepancy between the official statement and the visual record has drawn public criticism. Effect.uz has said it has sent a formal journalistic inquiry to Education Minister Erkinjon Turdimov seeking an official response on the matter. No reply from the minister had been received at the time of publication.

A Building Crisis, a Rushed Move

The underlying infrastructure problem at School No. 42 is not in dispute. A building constructed nearly seven decades ago being declared unfit for use is a serious finding, and the decision to relocate pupils to two alternative sites reflects a genuine emergency. What remains contested is how the physical move was managed — specifically, whether children were pressed into service as labour during their weekend, contrary to what the regional authority has told the public.

The episode illustrates a recurring tension in Uzbekistan’s education system between the urgency of managing crumbling school infrastructure and the accountability owed to families when official explanations diverge from documented reality.

Share.

Malika focuses on public datasets, government financial disclosures and evidence-based reporting. Her work uses public information to explain spending patterns, institutional performance and broader governance trends.