Independent news. Deeper insight. Uzbekistan and beyond.

Listen to the article

0:00
0:00

A ruling issued by an Uzbekistan Supreme Court judge on 13 November 2026 has drawn sharp criticism from legal observers for a practice that is becoming increasingly common in the country’s civil courts: dismissing a litigant’s arguments without engaging with a single one of them.

The case concerns a plaintiff identified as U.B., who worked for nearly five years as head of the Bukhara branch of the state institution “Uzbekistan National Metrology Institute.” In April 2025, U.B.’s employment contract was terminated on the basis of a resignation letter he says he wrote only because his employer promised him a different position within two months. When that promise was not kept, he went to court seeking reinstatement.

The Bukhara inter-district court rejected the claim in March 2026, ruling that the statutory deadline for filing had been missed. The Navoi regional court upheld that decision at both its appellate hearing in July and its supervisory review in October. Supreme Court judge M. Rabiyeva then declined, by ruling on 13 November, to refer the supervisory complaint to the Civil Cases Judicial Panel — the final avenue available to U.B.

A Ruling That Contradicts Itself

What makes the Supreme Court ruling striking, according to the analysis published by the legal outlet Effect.uz, is that the document’s own stated facts undermine its conclusions. The ruling records that the dismissal order was certified with the employer’s electronic digital signature on 21 April 2025, yet the same ruling states that U.B. was familiarised with the order on 18 April 2025 — three days before it was formally signed. The ruling offers no explanation for how an employee could be shown a document that did not yet legally exist.

The deadline question turns on when U.B. received a copy of the order, because Article 560 of the Labour Code starts the limitation clock from the date a copy is handed over. The ruling references an acknowledgement slip in the case file but does not specify when or to whom a copy was actually delivered. More significantly, a June 2026 forensic conclusion from the Samarkand inter-regional division of the Republican Centre for Forensic Examination found that the handwritten entries on that acknowledgement slip did not belong to U.B. That finding appears in the ruling itself — yet the court used the same slip as the basis for calculating when the deadline began. The forensic evidence favouring the plaintiff received no legal assessment.

Two further facts cited in the ruling also cut against the deadline finding. U.B.’s employment record book was collected on 23 April 2025 not by U.B. himself but by a third party acting under a power of attorney — a detail that undermines any inference that U.B. had personally received his dismissal documents by that date. And U.B.’s central argument — that his resignation letter was not voluntary but was written in reliance on his employer’s promise of a new post — was directly relevant to whether the deadline could be restored on grounds of a valid excuse. The ruling contains no sentence addressing it.

A Template Answer for Every Argument

All of U.B.’s substantive arguments were disposed of in a single formulaic sentence stating that they had been “examined and given the correct legal assessment by the supervisory instance of the regional court.” Which argument was examined, how, and why each was found unpersuasive is not stated anywhere in the document.

The pattern that emerges across the four levels of proceedings is one of circular endorsement: the district court relied on the deadline; the appellate court approved the district court; the regional supervisory panel approved the appellate court; and the Supreme Court judge noted that the regional court had already examined the matter. At no stage did any tribunal engage with the substance of U.B.’s case on its merits.

Uzbekistan’s Civil Procedure Code requires court decisions to be reasoned, and mandates that when a party’s arguments are rejected, the grounds for rejection must be stated. The Supreme Court Plenum has issued repeated guidance to lower courts on this obligation. The Effect.uz analysis argues that treating silence as a form of assessment — accepting a boilerplate formula in place of genuine reasoning — has itself become a recognised judicial technique, one grounded in convenience rather than law.

The publication calls on the Supreme Court President to examine the practice of issuing template rulings that ignore litigants’ arguments and to issue clear guidance; on the Supreme Judicial Council to place the reasoned-judgment requirement under dedicated oversight; and on the Judicial Qualification Board to apply the sanctions prescribed by law against judges who deliberately disregard statutory requirements and Plenum guidance. It also states that a petition to the Supreme Court President or Deputy President to annul the 13 November ruling will be filed — though it notes the problem extends well beyond a single case. When a court stops hearing arguments, it stops hearing justice.

Share.

Nodira covers legal developments, corruption-related court proceedings and judicial reform. Her work focuses on making complex legal issues and decisions understandable to the public.