Independent news. Deeper insight. Uzbekistan and beyond.

Listen to the article

0:00
0:00

The European Union has removed Alisher Usmanov from its sanctions list, yet German authorities are pressing ahead with a criminal tax investigation against the Uzbek-born billionaire that three independent specialists in German tax criminal law say is riddled with procedural failings and should be closed.

The investigation, opened in 2022, centres on allegations that Usmanov maintained a residence in Germany for more than a decade without filing tax returns. German newspaper Welt reviewed a legal opinion prepared by tax criminal law specialists Carsten Fehn, Bernd Josef Fehn and Jan Ole Schmiding, who concluded that Berlin lacks sufficient grounds for suspicion against Usmanov.

An Anonymous Tip, Shifting Figures and Google Street View

According to the experts’ assessment as reported by Welt, the investigation was triggered by an anonymous tip to German criminal police suggesting that a property in Germany might belong to Usmanov. Critically, that initial report concerned a possible sanctions violation — not a tax offence — and contained no information about tax wrongdoing.

The specialists also noted that the alleged sum of unpaid taxes shifted dramatically during the course of the investigation, moving from millions of euros to billions, with investigators providing no explanation for the discrepancy and no supporting evidence. The charges, the experts found, rest partly on unreliable circumstantial sources — including, the opinion states, data drawn from Google Street View.

The assessment further found that investigators ignored a range of exculpatory material they were obliged to consider, among them visa records, witness testimony, Russian tax documents and data held by Germany’s Federal Central Tax Office on Usmanov’s tax residency status.

Defence Kept From Case Files for Two Years

A separate procedural concern raised in the expert opinion is that Usmanov’s defence lawyers were not granted access to the case file until two years into the investigation — and even then did not receive full disclosure of the documents.

The specialists concluded that the investigation has been conducted in breach of proper procedure and that investigators have continued expanding the scope of allegations without first substantiating earlier ones with credible evidence. They recommended that the case be terminated and called on legislators to tighten criminal law norms to prevent political influence from bearing on such proceedings.

The EU’s removal of Usmanov from its sanctions list adds weight to the defence’s position, though German prosecutors have given no public indication they intend to halt the inquiry. Switzerland separately lifted sanctions against Usmanov’s sister, Gulbakhor Ismailova, in the spring of last year.

Share.

Nodira covers legal developments, corruption-related court proceedings and judicial reform. Her work focuses on making complex legal issues and decisions understandable to the public.