Listen to the article
Kazakhstan’s business ombudsman has told the prime minister that the country’s system for selecting companies for regulatory inspection is broken, disproportionate and, in thousands of cases each year, unlawful — and has proposed replacing it with a single data-driven risk platform built on OECD standards.
In an open letter dated November 11 to Prime Minister Olzhas Bektenov, ombudsman Kanat Nurov drew on figures from the Ministry of National Economy and the Committee for Legal Statistics and Special Records at the Prosecutor General’s Office to argue that on-site inspections have become a burden that punishes growth rather than targeting genuine risk. The ministry recorded 46,884 unscheduled inspections of private businesses in 2025 — 92.5 percent of all inspections that year. Prosecutors identified more than 1,500 of those as unlawful.
The inspection burden falls unevenly across business sizes in ways Nurov said could actively deter companies from expanding. Small businesses faced one inspection for every 64 firms. Medium-sized businesses averaged 2.5 inspections each; large privately owned companies averaged 4.8. That means medium-sized firms were inspected at more than 150 times the rate of small ones. Under many provisions of Kazakhstan’s Code of Administrative Offenses, fines automatically double when a business moves into the next size category, compounding the deterrent effect.
Large businesses bore 63 percent of the total administrative fine burden — 60.3 billion tenge (about $136 million) out of 96.4 billion tenge (about $217 million) collected across all sizes. Meanwhile, 43 percent of all inspections in 2025 found no violations at all, up from 37 percent the previous year, suggesting that a growing share of regulatory visits produce no enforcement outcome.
A Reform That Stalled on Launch
A 2021 reform was meant to fix exactly this problem. It called for an automated system that would group businesses by risk level and generate inspection lists and schedules, removing discretion — and the scope for pressure — from the process. The system was formally launched in January 2024 but has been largely inoperative since, Nurov said, because of persistent technical problems and a failure to fund ongoing support.
Of the 96 areas of government oversight designated for the reform, 66 were earmarked for automation. By 2026, automated tools were functioning in just 15 of those areas, according to ministry figures Nurov cited. The remaining 51 areas continue to operate without the risk-based selection the law envisaged.
Article 141 of Kazakhstan’s Entrepreneurial Code provides a fallback: regulators that lack an automated risk assessment system are capped at visiting no more than 5 percent of the businesses or sites under their oversight in any given area. But Nurov said the cap is effectively unenforceable because agencies do not maintain reliable counts of the businesses they oversee, making compliance impossible to verify.
What Nurov Is Asking For
The ombudsman’s proposals are specific. He called on the government to study how OECD member states assess regulatory risk, then establish common national rules specifying which data sources regulators must use and how they should verify data quality. Crucially, he asked that the criteria and their relative weighting be published, so businesses can understand what factors raise or lower their probability of inspection.
The rollout, he proposed, should start in the sectors where Kazakhstan’s Administrative Pressure Index records the heaviest regulatory burden on business. He also asked Bektenov to consider placing the legal statistics committee — which already tracks inspection data — in charge of the unified system, giving it both the mandate and the data infrastructure to enforce compliance across agencies.
Elsewhere in the region, Tajikistan has extended its moratorium on most inspections of small and medium-sized enterprises until January 1, 2029, with tax inspections remaining permitted — a blunter instrument than the risk-based approach Nurov is advocating, but one that reflects a shared regional concern about regulatory overreach.

